In light of the emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-powered technologies, and their increasing use in scholarly publishing, the Quarterly Journal of Defense Human Capital Management has established this policy statement to ensure transparency and provide guidance for authors, reviewers, editors, and readers. This policy will be reviewed and updated periodically to remain aligned with technological advancements and evolving best practices.
1. Use of Generative AI in Scholarly Writing
The use of artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-powered technologies in manuscript preparation is permitted solely for the purpose of improving readability and linguistic quality. Authors must recognize that they retain full responsibility for the accuracy, validity, and integrity of their manuscripts. Accordingly, AI tools must be used under human supervision and oversight. Authors are required to carefully review, verify, and edit AI-generated outputs, as these may contain inaccurate, incomplete, or biased information.
2. Disclosure of AI Use
Authors must transparently disclose any use of AI and related technologies in their submitted manuscripts.
3. AI Cannot Be Listed as an Author
Artificial intelligence and AI-powered technologies may not be credited as authors or co-authors. Authorship entails responsibilities and obligations that can only be fulfilled by human beings.
4. Images and Artwork
The use of AI to generate or modify images in submitted manuscripts is prohibited. The sole exception applies when AI is an integral part of the research design or methodology. In such cases, its use must be fully described in the Methods section.
The use of AI to generate artwork, including graphical abstracts, is not permitted unless prior approval has been obtained from the journal's editor and full compliance with intellectual property rights has been ensured.
1. Confidentiality
Reviewers must treat submitted manuscripts as confidential documents and must not upload manuscripts, or any part thereof, to generative AI tools. Doing so may violate the authors' confidentiality rights and intellectual property rights.
2. Prohibition of AI Use in Peer Review
The peer-review process requires critical thinking and independent scholarly judgment that cannot be delegated to AI technologies. Therefore, reviewers must not use AI tools to assist in the scholarly evaluation of submitted manuscripts.
1. Confidentiality
Editors must treat submitted manuscripts and all related correspondence as strictly confidential.
2. Prohibition of AI Use in Editorial Evaluation
Editors must not use AI tools to assist in evaluating manuscripts or making editorial decisions, as these processes require critical thinking and independent human judgment.
The Quarterly Journal of Defense Human Capital Management currently uses the Samim-e Noor similarity detection system to screen submitted manuscripts for plagiarism and other forms of textual similarity.
The journal continuously evaluates emerging technologies that may improve the publication process while ensuring compliance with confidentiality requirements and data privacy principles, thereby supporting authors, reviewers, and editors.
If AI tools have been used in preparing a manuscript, authors must include the following declaration in their submitted work:
Declaration of AI Use
“During the preparation of this work, the author(s) used [name of tool/service] for [purpose]. Following the use of this tool/service, the author(s) reviewed and edited the content and accept full responsibility for the content of the published work.”