Defense Human Capital Management

Defense Human Capital Management

Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Upon submission, all research articles undergo an initial screening by the journal office and the Editor-in-Chief to assess their suitability for the journal’s aims and scope, compliance with the Instructions for Authors, completeness of the submission documents, originality, and adherence to ethical requirements.

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial screening proceed to the double-anonymous peer review process. Before a final decision is made, each manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the relevant subject area. The identities of the authors are not disclosed to the reviewers, and the identities of the reviewers are not disclosed to the authors.

In the event of a substantial disagreement between the two reviewers’ reports, the Editor-in-Chief may seek an assessment from a third reviewer. The final decision to accept, request revisions, or reject a manuscript is made by the Editor-in-Chief based on the reviewers’ reports and the Editor-in-Chief’s independent assessment of the manuscript’s scientific merit.

If the Editor-in-Chief, the Managing Editor, a member of the Editorial Board, or a journal staff member is an author or co-author of a manuscript, that individual shall have no involvement in the selection of reviewers, access to information that could reveal the reviewers’ identities, or the final decision-making process. In such cases, the manuscript will be handled independently by another eligible member of the Editorial Board.

 

The identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential from one another throughout the peer-review process.

1. Manuscript Submission and Registration

All manuscripts must be submitted and registered through the journal’s official online submission system. Authors are required to prepare and submit their manuscripts in accordance with the journal’s Guide for Authors and the submission requirements published on its website. Submission of a manuscript constitutes confirmation of its originality, compliance with research ethics principles, and the absence of simultaneous submission to other journals.

2. Initial Manuscript Screening

Upon receipt, the journal’s editorial office evaluates the manuscript to determine whether it falls within the journal’s aims and scope, meets the requirements for scholarly structure and academic writing, includes complete author information, and complies with the fundamental principles of publication ethics.

If deficiencies or non-compliance with the journal’s requirements are identified, the manuscript will be returned to the corresponding author for preliminary revisions. Manuscripts that fall outside the journal’s scope or fail to meet minimum scholarly and structural requirements may be rejected at this stage.

3. Scholarly Evaluation and Reviewer Selection

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial screening are sent to at least two independent experts in the relevant subject area for scholarly evaluation. Reviewers are selected based on their academic expertise, research record, and absence of conflicts of interest.

The journal follows a double-anonymous peer-review process, whereby the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to one another during the evaluation process.

4. Peer Review and Reviewers’ Recommendations

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts in terms of originality, significance of the topic, soundness of the theoretical foundations, appropriateness of the methodology, accuracy of the analyses, quality of the findings, scholarly coherence, compliance with research ethics principles, and reliability of the cited sources.

Each reviewer submits an expert assessment to the journal, including recommendations for revisions and a recommendation regarding acceptance or rejection.

5. Editorial Decision

Upon receipt of the reviewers’ reports, the Editor-in-Chief or the designated academic editor evaluates the reviewers’ comments in conjunction with the journal’s scholarly standards and publication policies to determine the next stage of the editorial process.

Possible decisions include:

  • Acceptance
  • Acceptance subject to revisions
  • Major revisions and further review
  • Rejection

The final decision to accept or reject a manuscript rests with the Editor-in-Chief or the duly authorized editorial authority.

6. Manuscript Revision and Resubmission

When revisions are requested, the reviewers’ comments and the required changes are communicated to the corresponding author. Authors must submit the revised manuscript within the specified deadline, together with a detailed, reasoned response addressing each reviewer comment.

Where necessary, the revised manuscript may be returned to the reviewers for further evaluation. Submission of a revised manuscript does not guarantee its acceptance.

7. Final Editing and Preparation for Publication

Accepted manuscripts undergo final checks for language and style, structural consistency, accuracy of bibliographic information, and compliance with the journal’s formatting guidelines.

At this stage, author details, institutional affiliations, abstracts, keywords, references, and other required information are verified or revised as necessary. The final version of the manuscript is then provided to the corresponding author for final approval.

8. Publication

Following completion of all scholarly and technical procedures, the article is published in an issue of the journal.

The dates of submission, acceptance, and publication are recorded on the article’s webpage and, where applicable, in the full text. Published articles are made publicly available in accordance with the journal’s open-access policy and the publication license specified on its website.

9. Publication Ethics and Editorial Independence

The journal is committed to upholding publication ethics, maintaining the confidentiality of information, ensuring reviewer independence, preventing conflicts of interest, and treating authors fairly and impartially.

Submitted manuscripts and their associated information are used exclusively for purposes related to the editorial evaluation and publication process. Any suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, data manipulation, or other forms of research misconduct will be investigated in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics policies.

10. Confidentiality and Editorial Responsibility

All stages of manuscript evaluation and peer review are conducted confidentially. Decisions regarding manuscript acceptance or rejection are based on scholarly quality, relevance to the journal’s scope, peer-review outcomes, and the journal’s publication requirements.

Factors such as institutional affiliation, academic status, or other non-scholarly considerations must not influence editorial decisions.